Employment Loss and Post-COVID Recovery Across U.S. Metro Areas

2025-11-12T08:15:10-06:00

In April 2020, total payroll employment in the United States fell by an unprecedented 20.5 million, following a loss of 1.4 million in March, as the COVID-19 pandemic brought the economy to a sudden halt. The unemployment rate surged by 10.4 percentage points to 14.8% in April. It was the highest rate effectively since the Great Depression. Tracking the labor market impact is critical for understanding the follow-on effect on home building activity during the last five years. As people stayed at home and businesses shut down under government directives, millions of Americans lost their jobs. Initial unemployment insurance claims soared to 2.9 million during the week of March 21, 2020. For the following 19 consecutive weeks, more than one million Americans filed for unemployment each week, totaling roughly 50.9 million claims over just five months. While the national labor market suffered an unprecedented collapse in both speed and depth, the effects varied significantly across U.S. metro areas. Local economies experience dramatically different outcomes depending on their industrial composition, the feasibility of remote work, and the strictness of local public health restrictions. A map of metro areas across the United States reveals striking variations in employment losses from February 2020 to the pandemic’s employment trough. Nonfarm employment payrolls declined by anywhere from 5% to 35% across 393 metro areas. Kahului-Wailuku, Hawaii, experienced the steepest job losses, with employment plummeting by 35%. This metro area’s deep dependence on tourism and hospitality, particularly in accommodation and food services, left it vulnerable to travel restrictions and widespread shutdown. Similarly, Atlantic City-Hammonton, New Jersey, as a prime tourism destination, was devastated by pandemic-related closures. By May 2020, its total employment dropped 34% from the February 2020 level. Some metro areas experienced major setbacks tied to their dominant industries. In Elkhart-Goshen, Indiana, as the heart of the U.S. RV manufacturing industry, employment plunged 34% as production ground to a halt. At the other end of the spectrum, Logan, UT-ID, recorded the mildest downturn, with a relatively modest 5% employment drop, reflecting a more resilient local economy. In sheer numbers, New York-Newark-Jersey City, New York-New Jersey saw the largest employment losses in the nation, shedding nearly 2 million jobs, or about 20% of its pre-pandemic workforce. Los Angeles–Long Beach–Anaheim, California, followed closely, losing 1.1 million jobs, about 17% of its February 2020 level. Despite the historic scale of these losses, the U.S. labor market rebounded faster than many anticipated. Within just 26 months, overall employment had fully recovered, surpassing its February 2020 level to reach 152.4 million by June 2022. Yet, as with the initial losses, the recovery varied widely across metro areas. By August 2025, 93 of the 393 metro areas had still not regained their pre-pandemic employment levels. Lake Charles, Louisiana, remains the slowest to recover, with employment at only 87% of its February 2020 level. The region’s setbacks have been compounded by multiple disasters—COVID-19, followed by Hurricanes Laura and Delta in 2020—that disrupted both infrastructure and labor markets. Kankakee, Illinois (92% recovered), and Weirton–Steubenville, West Virginia–Ohio (93%), also lagged, highlighting how recovery can be delayed by structural and regional challenges. In contrast, many other metro areas have not only recovered but expanded beyond their pre-pandemic employment levels. As of August 2025, 300 metro areas have fully rebounded, with some even booming. Wildwood–The Villages, Florida, leads the nation with employment reaching 127% of its February 2020 level, followed by St. George, Utah, at 125%. Notably, the areas that suffered the sharpest employment declines in 2020 did not necessarily experience the slowest recoveries. Las Vegas–Henderson–North Las Vegas, Nevada, for instance, lost 277,900 jobs, about 26% of its workforce, but has rebounded strongly, reaching 109% of its pre-pandemic employment. By contrast, Enid, Oklahoma, which lost just 1,600 jobs, remains slightly below its February 2020 level, still 2% short of full recovery. The story of employment loss and recovery across U.S. metro areas underscores the uneven geography of the COVID-19 economy. The resilience of local economies has since reshaped the post-pandemic landscape, revealing not only where recovery has taken root but also where it remains incomplete. And of course, the health of local labor markets has important impacts on the status of local home building and remodeling conditions.

Employment Loss and Post-COVID Recovery Across U.S. Metro Areas2025-11-12T08:15:10-06:00

Remodelers on the Rise: How Renovation is Reshaping Residential Construction

2025-11-10T08:18:08-06:00

As the nation’s housing stock continues to age and new homes remain out of reach for many buyers, remodeling is capturing a growing share of the residential construction market, both in terms of the number of firms and employment. With most U.S. households unable to afford new construction, renovation has become a more practical and cost-effective alternative to improve housing conditions, driving demand on the consumer side. On the supply side, many home builders undertake remodeling projects to grow their business. NAHB’s analysis of the quarter-century of Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW) data suggests that the rise of remodelers is a sustained structural shift rather than a temporary post-pandemic surge. Remodeling Firms’ Share in Residential Construction is RisingOver the past 25 years, the number of remodeling establishments has nearly doubled—from fewer than 69,000 in 2000 to more than 128,000 in the first quarter of 2025. Remodelers now represent over half (56%) of all residential building construction (RBC) establishments. By contrast, during the mid-2000s housing boom, remodelers’ share consistently hovered around 38–39%, when the market was dominated by home builders, including new single-family and multifamily general contractors as well as speculative (spec) home builders. Although the remodeling sector was not immune to the 2008 housing crash, its losses were modest compared to the contraction of home building. Between 2007 and 2012, the number of remodeling establishments fell by 8%, while roughly one-third of home builders went out of business. As a result, the remodeler’s share of the RBC sector rose sharply after the crash, reaching 46% in 2011, and has continued to climb steadily ever since. During the post-pandemic housing boom, driven by low mortgage rates, the rise of remote work, and a renewed demand for larger living spaces, both remodelers and home builders experienced solid growth. However, remodelers expanded their ranks at a faster pace, with their share of RBC firms climbing to 54% by 2022. Less sensitive to fluctuations in mortgage rates than home builders, remodelers have continued to grow even amid a series of aggressive Federal Reserve rate hikes that sharply increased the cost of home purchases and slowed new construction. As of 2024, remodeling firms account for 56% of all RBC establishments. Remodeling Employment Share in RBC is Rising In the overall construction industry, which encompasses residential and non-residential building construction, as well as heavy/civil engineering construction, land subdivision, and specialty trade contractors, it is the latter that dominate the overall sector employment. However, the government employment surveys cannot identify what portion of subcontractors’ business is devoted to remodeling. As a result, RBC is the subsector that allows tracking the remodeling trends best. The analysis of employment trends in residential building construction reveals a similar pattern, with remodelers generating a rising number and share of jobs, largely at the expense of single-family general contractors. As of 2024, the remodeling sector accounted for almost half (49%) of RBC workers. In contrast, during the housing boom of the mid-2000s, only 30% of payroll employees worked for remodelers, while single-family general contractors employed 63% of the RBC workforce. The shift is even more pronounced within the production (nonsupervisory) workforce of the RBC industry.  More than half (51.2%) of these skilled craftsmen now work for remodeling firms, compared with roughly 30% in the early 2000s, according to NAHB’s analysis of historical data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Current Employment Statistics (CES) survey. Multifamily general contractors, who subcontract out most of their construction work, account for a smaller share of home building jobs but have also gained ground. Fueled by strong multifamily activity in 2022–2023, their share of RBC employment grew to 5% by 2024. For-sale builders account for an additional 6%. The typical remodeling firm remains small, averaging between 3 and 4 employees per establishment, comparable to levels observed during the mid-2000s housing boom. This stability suggests that the overall rise in remodeling employment stems primarily from the creation of new firms or the reclassification of home builders shifting toward renovation work as remodelers. It is likely that, as market conditions change, some home builders, particularly smaller single-family general contractors, pivot toward renovation projects to stay and grow their business. The remodeling sector’s lower barriers to entry, smaller upfront investments compared to new construction, and fewer regulatory hurdles make the transition easier. As more companies view remodeling as their primary activity and revenue source, more will be reclassified as remodeling establishments in the official data reporting. This is because data collection in the U.S. is guided by the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS). Under NAICS, a company self-classifies and chooses the industry code that best captures its primary activity. In some surveys, such as the Economic Census, the Census Bureau emphasizes revenue sources as a primary metric for categorizing businesses. The steadily rising number of remodelers and the jobs they create underscores that renovation has become the reliable engine driving growth in the residential construction sector.

Remodelers on the Rise: How Renovation is Reshaping Residential Construction2025-11-10T08:18:08-06:00

How COVID-19 Reshaped the U.S. Labor Market and Housing Demand

2025-10-22T09:19:14-05:00

Between February 2020 and June 2022, the U.S. labor market experienced the deepest downturn on record followed by the fastest recovery in at least a century. The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted every corner of the economy, forcing massive shutdowns and triggering record job losses across all industries. Yet, in just two years, the labor market rebounded with remarkable speed, marking a historic recovery that continues to reshape both employment trends and the broader economy. Overall Employment Recovery At the beginning of 2020, the U.S. economy was enjoying a “Goldilocks” moment at the end of Trump’s first term with the longest continuous stretch of job growth on record. The unemployment rate remained near a 50-year low of 3.5%, job openings were steady, and wage growth was modestly outpacing inflation. Then, the COVID-19 pandemic struck, reshaping the labor market dramatically. In April 2020 alone, the U.S. lost roughly 20.5 million jobs—an unprecedented drop since data collection began in 1939—bringing total nonfarm payroll employment to its lowest level since February 2011. By the end of that spring, the economy shed nearly 22.9 million jobs due to shutdowns and restrictions. Meanwhile, the unemployment rate soared to 14.8% in April 2020, the highest level since the Great Depression. This recession was not only the deepest in U.S. history but also the fastest to recover. It took just 26 months for overall employment to return to pre-pandemic levels—a speed unmatched by any previous downturn. In February 2020, total employment stood at 152.3 million but plunged 14.4% to 130.4 million by April. From there, the labor market rebounded relentlessly, surpassing the February 2020 level to reach 152.4 million by June 2022. Notably, May 2020 saw the largest monthly job gain on record, signaling the beginning of a historic recovery. Uneven Industrial Recoveries While the overall U.S. labor market made a remarkable recovery from the historic COVID-19 downturn, the path of recovery varied widely across industries. Among all the major industries, the leisure and hospitality sector was hit the hardest, losing approximately 8.2 million jobs—nearly half their workforce—in just two months. However, by August 2025, this sector had not only fully recovered but exceeded its pre-pandemic employment level. Other major industries that experienced significant job losses include health care and social assistance (down by nearly 2.3 million jobs), retail trade (2.27 million), and professional and business services (2.26 million). All of these sectors have not only recovered but also expanded beyond their pre-pandemic employment levels by August 2025. Government employment, although not driven by market forces and constraints, declined by about 1.46 million jobs but has rebounded to 103% of its pre-pandemic size. Construction, another vital sector, lost around 1.09 million jobs but has experienced a robust recovery, now standing at 109% of the February 2020 level. However, not all sectors have bounced back fully. Manufacturing, especially in durable goods, remains just shy of full recovery, at 99% of its pre-pandemic employment level after losing 933,000 jobs. The mining and logging sector, which lost 145,000 jobs, continues to lag, with employment still at just 89% of its February 2020 level. These industries continue to face challenges in returning to their pre-pandemic workforce size. Meanwhile, several sectors, such as private educational services, transportation and warehousing, non-durable goods manufacturing, wholesale trade, information, financial activities, and utilities, all experienced smaller job losses relative to the hardest-hit industries and have now surpassed their pre-pandemic employment levels, with transportation and warehousing showing the strongest rebound at 117% of the February 2020 level. From Job Market to Housing Market: Pandemic Reshapes Housing Market The labor market recovery has occurred alongside a broader reshaping of household behavior, particularly around how and where Americans live. As lockdowns and remote work kept people home, the share of expenditures devoted to at-home consumption rose sharply. This shift had profound effects on housing demand. In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Federal Reserve lowered the federal funds rate to a target range of 0% to 0.25% in March 2020 and remained at this historically low level for nearly two years to stimulate borrowing and spending to support the economy. Fueled by historically low interest rates, the housing market experienced an unprecedented surge. Sales of both new and existing single-family homes soared. New home sales peaked at more than 160% of 2019 levels by mid-2020, while existing home sales also rose sharply. However, as inflationary pressures grew, the Federal Reserve began raising rates aggressively in 2022. This tightening cycle significantly cooled the housing market, particularly for existing homes. Existing home sales fell below pre-pandemic levels and continued to trend downward through 2025. In contrast, new home sales—while volatile—generally remained above 2019 levels in the past two years. A shortage of resale inventory, coupled with homeowners hesitant to give up locked-in low mortgage rates, led many buyers to turn to new construction despite elevated interest rates. Looking Ahead: Easing Rates and a Potential Market Rebound In recent months, there have been signs of a potential rebound in the housing market. Following the Federal Reserve’s rate cut in September 2025, mortgage rates fell below 6.5% for the first time this year. As of last week, the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate had dropped to 6.27%. With additional Fed rate cuts expected in the coming quarters, lower borrowing costs and improving inventory levels could stimulate housing market activity on both the buying and selling sides of the industry. Discover more from Eye On Housing Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

How COVID-19 Reshaped the U.S. Labor Market and Housing Demand2025-10-22T09:19:14-05:00

About My Work

Phasellus non ante ac dui sagittis volutpat. Curabitur a quam nisl. Nam est elit, congue et quam id, laoreet consequat erat. Aenean porta placerat efficitur. Vestibulum et dictum massa, ac finibus turpis.

Recent Works

Recent Posts